Plagiarism in the Indian Institutes of Technology: The Telegraph

October 13, 2010 at 6:04 pm 1 comment

Following is a report from the Telegraph:

New Delhi, Oct 10: Scientific misconduct has surfaced in five Indian Institutes of Technology in independent cases that reflect unethical practices in the pursuit of research touching even the nation’s elite institutions.

Scientists familiar with these cases have said they involve plagiarism and poor supervision of young researchers, and show how senior faculty turned into coauthors of scientific papers even while oblivious to their detailed contents.

Authorities at the IIT, Kharagpur, have removed the head of its physics department who was accused of not granting a colleague credit due in a research paper — a charge upheld by an internal institutional inquiry, but denied by the professor.

Two international journals have retracted research papers coauthored by senior faculty at IIT, New Delhi, and IIT, Kanpur, on grounds of plagiarism — one paper copied text from Wikipedia. And the Society for Scientific Values, a 24-year old non-government ethics watchdog for scientists, is investigating complaints of scientific misconduct in two other IITs.

The journal, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, has retracted a 2009 paper coauthored by Anup Ghosh, a professor of polymer science at the IIT, New Delhi, Devesh Avasthi and Pawan Kulriya at the Inter University Accelerator Centre, Sharif Ahmad from the Jamia Milia Islamia University, and Shashi Chawla from the Amity School of Engineering.

The journal said the authors had “plagiarised parts of a paper that had already appeared” in another journal and described the work as a “severe abuse of the scientific publishing system.”

Another journal, Biotechnology Advances , has retracted two review papers coauthored by Ashok Kumar and his students at the department of biological sciences at IIT, Kanpur, for plagiarism. The journal said one paper had plagiarised text from several previously published papers, and the other had extracted text from Wikipedia without citations.

Neither Kumar nor Ghosh were available for comments. But Avasthi, a scientist at the IUAC claimed that a research scholar had plagiarised text and assigned coauthorships to senior faculty.

But scientists tracking ethics say this is no excuse.

“Many young people are unaware that plagiarism is a serious offense. But supervisors should own responsibility for content of papers — and not merely accept authorships to add to the number of papers in their resumes,” said Kasturi Lal Chopra, a former director of the IIT, Kharagpur, and president of the SSV.

An inquiry by Chopra on request from the IIT Kharagpur has observed that the head of its physics department professor R.N.P Choudhary had denied legitimate credit to a colleague A.K.Thakur in a research paper.

Choudhary has denied wrongdoing. He claimed that a student, who was the first author of the paper, had without his knowledge made him the corresponding author. He also said that he has had 29 joint papers with his accuser —Thakur — in the past, and that Thakur had not contributed to this paper.

“We need to teach ethics as part of the curriculum in MSc or at least at PhD level courses,” said Ravinder Kotnala, a physicist at the National Physical Laboratory, New Delhi, and SSV secretary.

The SSV typically gets about 10 to 12 complaints of scientific misconduct each month, most often from within the academic institutions. Many are frivolous, but we take up the serious ones for independent investigation, Kotnala said.

He requested that the identities of the two other IITs not be revealed because the investigations into the complaints are still incomplete. One complaint claims researchers fabricated data, while the other claims that the same experimental data was used unjustifiably to generate multiple research papers.

“Ideally, even school students need to be sensitised to ethics,” Kotnala said. “I’ve seen plenty of school science projects entirely based on material copied from the Internet.”

The SSV has long urged India’s scientific departments to introduce ethics training in academic institutions and create an agency with legal teeth to monitor ethics in scientific affairs.

The SSV has itself conducted workshops on ethics, but its members have limited time for such activities. “It’s also a dirty job — no one likes to police scientists,” one member of the SSV executive committee said.


Entry filed under: Higher Education, India.

Orissa demands Rs 1516 crore as drought assistance:PTI reports Orissa govt. declares 90 blocks in 15 districts as drought-hit: The Pioneer

1 Comment Add your own

  • 1. ajay  |  November 1, 2010 at 12:02 pm

    I am really saddened to read this report. A great teacher, great human being like RNP sir is made to suffer due to some base less allegations is disturbing to us . RNP sir has more than 450 publications… His publication record in the past 6 years: In 2004 its 26; 2005 its 26; 2006 its 21; 2007 its 36; 2008 its 40; 2009 its 36; 2010 its 14 & counting (Data from ISI web of Knowledge). His h-index is 19.. with over 2200 citations.. This list his just journal publications.. there are many more conference proceedings, invited lectures, book chapters.. that I haven’t included..
    I have known Prof. RNP Choudhary sir since a decade. His work-ethics, his knowledge, his helpful nature .. is a role-model to every budding researcher… Writing more about this great man is like “‘spitting in the sky ”.. Leveling frivolous allegations against this great man is simply unacceptable. I request younger generation that particularly in Research Field do not solicit from any body as co-author where you have not contibuted, ‘First deserve than desire’. Today Basic Resaech in India is on the cross road. There is a vacuum in the basis research, if such news comes from the Premium institute from IITs, definitely it is a loss to the nation. We scientific community will have no face value in the society. I am sharing few bitter truth what the young researcher from the Universities Scholars are facing during his Ph. D period particularly while taking the experimental data. I have also suffered while taking data from the concerned lab and we have to accommodate some fellow scientists of that particular lab in the paper, otherwise they make impossible from next time. Many of my data have been not published by me due to these obvious reasons of long wish list of coauthor and during Ph. D period we are just slave. There is mad rush to increase the paper number by putting our name in head or tail by any means.

    We have forgotten that Scientific Instrument belongs to the Nation and poor country like us is still affording to invest in building Big Research Lab. We scientists are having a National obligation in helping the young Scholars. All Researchers of premium lab make sure that the young researchers get the experimental data easily and our fellow colleagues of that lab do not solicit as coauthor unless he has contributed in the papers scientifically. At last once again I request my young researchers to maintain ethics in the Research otherwise we will have no reply for our 2nd generation and we cannot motivate our young students to join the research.

    I request our HT correspondent to highlight the pain of young researchers and should be careful while publishing in generalized way by glossing the entire story as a gospel truth, otherwise some interested group will exploit the truth.
    I pray mighty god to give strength to Prof RNP Choudhary so that he can breathe his rest life in peace. He will forget this entire episode as a bad dream.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed



Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 464 other subscribers

%d bloggers like this: